Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | _940h's commentslogin

What sort of crime are you envisioning that exploiting this would fall under? It's not always fraud to satisfy a poorly written contract, although that is commonly the case.


Wire fraud, at minimum. This would constitute direct theft. Very similar cases have been tried and convicted several times now.


Everything is wire fraud / securities fraud


Someone has been reading Matt Levine


Despite what many programmers think, code is not law.

Just like a bug in a smart lock does not allow you to enter a house because "you were allowed in".


Taking advantage of bad contracts can be legal depending on various nuanced circumstances. If the potential payout is lucrative, then it makes sense to consult with legal counsel first.

I am not making a judgement about this specific case.



That person committed fraud. My point wasn't even about cryptocurrency or DeFi.

Here's a simplified hypothetical example to help you understand the legal nuance: I offer all of my money to the first person that can solve 5x5, and I errantly believe that it's a difficult problem to solve.


Can you provide a more real-world example? I don't understand what point you are making, if it isn't about making money via cryptocurrency. When you say "bad contracts", I assume you are talking about smart contracts. Is that not the case?


This is greenwashing. You're still positively valuing the past harms from proof of work.

Solving the past harms means starting from scratch, not giving value to people who previously wasted electricity.


The "Etherium merge moment" is entirely different and it irks me to see it compared favorably with this project. It didn't 'solve' proof of work. It assigned positive value to past environmental harms. It prevents more proof of work, but doesn't solve past harms.

The only 'solution' (more a mitigation) to Etherium proof of work's environmental harms is to devalue it.

Unlike your example, this project actually seems to be a net positive for society that wasn't built on top of unnecessary harms.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: