Did wonder about the review, it probably sold well in the news papers and part of me thinks that the Odyssey team might even agree with her, but IMHO it's mostly overblown?
The movie is good an wildly successful, and maybe I've gotten less jaded, but felt like her criticism did not land ( saying that as someone who loves to poke holes at things and reading a good polemic).
She's entitled to her views, and others are entitled to think, like you, that her review is overblown.
My view is she has some good points about script and plot, given her expertise is in writing, but she's under-emphasising the importance of the visual arts.
Remember that Slashdot's review of the iPod was "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame.". Not everybody has to like the popular thing.
I quite like watching Yahtzee's Fully Ramblomatic reviews. He's known for giving most games a kicking, but he does highlight what's good in a game as well as its bad points. I'd rather hear what he has to say than get a adverising puff-piece review from IGN. Even for games that I strongly enjoyed, he usually raises good points about them that I'd agree with.
Shower thought: But how often per week do you run the pelican these days?
And do you have it automated at this point or would the automation take out the meaning of the benchmark?
Hope this becomes a cultural norm outside of HN. You can have AI written text that had some actual human effort put into it [1], but sloppy AI written content should only be meant for anohter AI consumers and not humans.
In my enterprise-seated account I see slightly different options available (vs. my personal account) in the Capabilities section:
Search and reference chats
Allow Claude to search for relevant details in past chats.
Generate memory from chat history (Legacy)
Allow Claude to remember relevant context from your chats. Memory includes your entire chat history with Claude.
The first option was defaulted to on, if I recall.
But it kind of conflicts with the contract we have with them. My company has an enterprise contract that says "no data retention" but then each user can decide to enable it unilateral?
If you're talking about Claude Code it's in ~/.claude/projects/<encoded dir name>/memory/MEMORY.md. So they're not really retaining it, it's just something that your harness loads in.
Unless you're a contracting agency!
reply