Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The FBI cannot get past this layer

Yes, it can, and I explained exactly how in the original post. It's true I got some of the technical details wrong, but the substance of the post was and is correct.



The technical details in this case really are everything, so it would make sense to get flagged out of existence if you got them wrong.

To be clear, I'm not one of the flaggers, but I can understand some potential motivation there. There is already a lot of noise on this topic.


One of the technical details is that disjunctive claims are true if any of their constituent elements are true. My claim was of the form, "The iPhone is vulnerable to attack. Here is one attack. If that doesn't work, here's a second attack." The first attack doesn't work, but the second one does. Hence the overall claim -- that the iPhone is vulnerable -- was (and remains) correct.

So should you be flagged to death because you got this wrong?


The second attack was added in an update after you were criticised, no? It hardly counts.


No, it was in the original post.

" they could use a copy of the chip to try five different PIN codes, and then replace the chip with a fresh copy of the original and try five more. Lather, rinse, repeat. At worst this would take about a week or so."


>> Yes, it can, and I explained exactly how in the original post. It's true I got some of the technical details wrong, but the substance of the post was and is correct

No you were wrong. You claimed that if the FBI was competent they could retrieve the key from the flash. There were no technical details discussed at all. (you could trivially google this issue and find out what you suggested doesn't work)

The ACLU is describing an attack on the PIN not the key. You acknowledge this in another comment on this thread so I have no idea why you are claiming here that the FBI can get past the encryption in any way; which as others have said doesn't work.


> The ACLU is describing an attack on the PIN not the key

Yes. And so did I.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: