Hacker News
new
|
past
|
comments
|
ask
|
show
|
jobs
|
submit
login
jdbernard
on Sept 12, 2019
|
parent
|
context
|
favorite
| on:
Two California hikers found a family's message in ...
Nice place for an Oxford comma.
laumars
on Sept 12, 2019
|
next
[–]
I was thinking this too. I'm generally a big fan of the Oxford comma.
hervature
on Sept 12, 2019
|
prev
|
next
[–]
Just an fyi, Oxford comma only applies to lists of 3 or more. I think this is just a dangling modifier.
mikeash
on Sept 12, 2019
|
parent
|
next
[–]
This is a list of three: Whitson, his son, and his girlfriend.
ant6n
on Sept 12, 2019
|
root
|
parent
|
next
[–]
Girlfriend of the whitson or the his son?
mikeash
on Sept 12, 2019
|
root
|
parent
|
next
[–]
Beats me!
lonelappde
on Sept 12, 2019
|
prev
|
next
[–]
The Oxford comma isn't the issue here. The issue is that "his" binds both son and girlfriend, and therefore needs an "and" in front of it. It's not grammatical as is.
rpmisms
on Sept 12, 2019
|
parent
|
next
[–]
It would still read perplexingly. The Oxford comma isn't a tool for the inept; rather, the ept.
Spare_account
on Sept 12, 2019
|
root
|
parent
|
next
[–]
It's interesting how sometimes what appears to be a prefix, isn't.
rpmisms
on Sept 12, 2019
|
root
|
parent
|
next
[–]
That is an affront up with which I will not put.
Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4
Guidelines
|
FAQ
|
Lists
|
API
|
Security
|
Legal
|
Apply to YC
|
Contact
Search: