Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Considering that it's the poorer people having more children it seems like the obvious answer is that most children are unplanned or the product of dim people with a figure it out later attitude.


> the product of dim people with a figure it out later attitude

I wonder how many of the "figure it out later" attitude people overlap the "absolute faith in higher power" people? Poorer people possibly have more subscribers to religious faith?

A decline in the religious population, that comforted themselves with wellbeing of their offspring being a matter of prayer and ritual and whatnot, has had some impact on peoples' outlook in this matter?


I think that narrative itself is fairly dim.

Consider a much more reasonable alternative - Having children can be seen as a path to traditional success by those who have very limited financial options.

By having a child - they gain a sense of purpose that is just utterly absent in most of our menial jobs. Further - Most people enjoy many aspects of their childhood, and having a child is a chance to pass on that joy and relive it.

Finally - additional children can bring additional revenue and help on the long term. If you know you have no job security, no money for savings, no pension, no 401k, and a low social security payout due to low earnings - children can be a way to have some semblance of retirement, and a safety net in old age.

---

Is there some overlap where it's also a consequence on not thinking through your decisions? Sure - probably. But that answer is simplistic.

For every complex question there's an answer that's short, simple, and wrong.


It's not really figure it out later. They have reasons like they will take care in the old age. If all of my peers can why can't I etc. Also, it's more of modern concept to actively not have children, which is not really permeated to all economic groups.

Atleast in India.

In other news, Lalu Prasad Yadav's daughter gave her one kidney to him yesterday. Where point 1 literally panned out.


I believe it’s hope relative to your personal circumstance that drives hopes for the next generation.

Do I think the next generation will have a better life than I had?

That’s easier to answer yes to if you started with little because the baseline is low.

For the squeezed middle in countries that have stopped developing? Probably not given the current trajectory




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: