Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Basically all Mediterranean dishes are cooked on the olive oil, for which you can find many sources claiming that it is extraordinarily healthy.

However, I am starting to be wary of this claim because olive oil has a _lot_ of saturated fats when compared to other food, roughly around 15-16g per 100g.

To put this figure into the context: 20% cooking cream, which is usually considered unhealthy because of its high saturated fats ratio, has about the same amount of saturated fats as olive oil, 14-15g per 100g. Saturated fats in butter are exceptionally high, 51g per 100g.

What was surprising to me is that even the sunflower oil, an oil which is frowned upon because it's refined, has _less_ of the saturated fats than olive oil, roughly around 13g per 100g.

All the rest of the food which we normally consume is in the region of 1-5g per 100g, including the eggs which have 1g of saturated fats per 100g.

By knowing for the fact that saturated fats are unhealthy, these stats seem to suggest that olive oil is not as healthy as it is generally considered.



> By knowing for the fact that saturated fats are unhealthy

This is simply not true, much less a "fact". This myth most probably comes from the good old American Heart Association who base their opinion of a study way back in the 1960s which was since proven to have been of extremely low quality. There is a ton of info about this online (including scientific studies, not just blog posts), pro and contra, you can read them yourself and then decide who you believe.

And butter and olive oil are one of the most healthy foods you can consume in my opinion <= there you have another point of view on the internet :)


Olive oil is not a saturated fat, so you may be conflating some things here.

Besides, the AMA also uses the research from all the other decades from the 1960s until now to make their recommendations.


It very much is saturated fat when compared to other food that we take, and which is exactly why I wanted to convey in my original comment that it doesn't appear to be that healthy when you put things into perspective.


Right, as if the American Heart Association was the only organization in world to examine the effects of saturated fats to our health, and as if the last study on that topic has been done half a century ago.

Thanks for your advice but unless you're willing to share that "ton of info" to support your rather absurd claim, I'll stick to my common sense.


Someone just pointed you toward "a ton of info" that you could find if you only bothered. You chose to patently disregard with the audacity of suggesting it's up to them to hold your hand and spoon-feed you this info that you're intentionally choosing to ignore. Do us a favor and re-read the guidelines regarding "good faith" and until then, get off this site.


I bothered and it's nonsense. Hence I asked for more information to share so that i can better understand the point being made. And now with that said, why don't you f off please? Thank you


So the mediterranean diet is bad because olive oil although everything point in the other direction ?

Sometimes you have to look at the bigger picture


No, I enjoy Mediterranean food and cousine every day. I almost exclusively use olive oil as well.

What I meant is what I tried to communicate in my last sentence: olive oil does not appear to be that healthy when put into the perspective with other food we use in kitchen.

With that in mind, I think that general recommendation and hype around the olive oil can be dangerous if not taken carefully.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: