Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Swimmers in Fleishhacker Pool which closed in 1971.

That’s gotta be the biggest swimming pool I’ve seen. I was born in ‘74 (hello, fellow Gen X-er) and we went to various public pools through the summer. The biggest was an “olympic sized” pool 20min driving distance from our house - and this one looks double that from the camera’s perspective.



The original Broad Ripple Park (Indianapolis) Pool was the "largest in the world" at one point (250' x 500'). I knew people who swam in it, but it had been turned into basketball courts by the time I saw the former pool. Shortly after that, it was removed.

The US swimming Olympic tryouts were held there in 1924 and 1952.

https://indyencyclopedia.org/broad-ripple-park/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ifFaKeimuA


What’s really interesting/sad is there used to be tons of really large pools created as part of depression era recovery act public works programs. Then later, when equal rights law allowed non-whites to use the pools equally, cities and communities closed the pools and filled them up instead of allowing integration.

https://www.kqed.org/forum/2010101893972/why-arent-there-mor...


That’s a trope that doesn’t bear on the Fleishhacker pool closure. There’s been a shift I think in govt spending from things like recreation to social services. If you took the SF homeless and other social services budgets including state Medi-cal funding that dwarfs recreational spending - and this is a shift in allocation over time. And I thought pools were racially integrated historically and it’s when they integrated genders the race panic stupidity came in big time. Especially in south some bad behavior.


My dad explained this to me as well, that most of the places closed up rather than admit minorities. As a result, the communities kind of collapsed.



FWIW this has nothing to do with why this specific pool closed. It fell into disrepair and was used as a parking lot for the zoo.


Sure, Fleischacker pool was underfunded for years and fell into disrepair and then closed in 1971. But why was it underfunded, and why was there not enough money to repair it?

Compare that to Kitsilano Pool in Canada. It was consistently repaired and upgraded over time, a fact well documented in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitsilano_Pool


NIMBYism has been ruining America for a century.


The term you're looking for is "racism", and it's been ruining America for a lot longer than a century, and it still is, in fact it's on a resurgence, as we all well know (but some try to deny).


The terms aren’t mutually exclusive


Calling blatant racism "NIMBY" is whitewashing.

And "for a century" is historically incorrect and revisionist, if you were actually talking about racism, which I don't believe you were.

What was the real point you were trying to make? It sounds to me you're offering "NIMBY", which has nothing to do with race, as an alternative theory to counter the parent's point that it's actually racism, which is extremely well documented and not legitimately contested, and has been going on for a lot longer than a century.

Are you literally saying people don't want swimming pools in their back yards? Really??! That's news to me. Or is it actually that they don't want black people in their public swimming pools? That's not what "NIMBY" means, but mutually exclusively exactly what "racism" means.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NIMBY


Before it was demolished, had the chance to swim in the Moskva pool: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moskva_Pool

At 6,7m gallons (25k cubic meters) volume it was a bit larger and freshwater. The big deal about it was that it was used year round in Moscow. It was quite the experience to swim in it in the winter at -15C. -20C was the official operating limit.



Sutro Baths was just north at the end of Ocean Beach, but half as long:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sutro_Baths

It's a bummer there's nothing like these places there today.


It’s a two hour plane ride away, but there’s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitsilano_Pool


Nobody should be boarding a plane to swim in a pool somewhere else.


There are the casting pools in GGP, which are quite large, and (given the few people who use them for casting) could be converted into swimming pools.


6.5 million gallons of heated sea water. No wonder it couldn't keep running.


They could have just stuck a nuclear reactor in it. Two problems solved.


Don't go too close to those spent fuel rods on the deep end.



Its fine just wear a lead jacket while swimming on that end


Because the water doesn't block the radiation? uhm?


We had a 120m x 50m public pool around as a kid. It was fantastic, more like swimming in a lake. It got replaced by two stainless steel contraptions (one regular 50m pool and one "play pool"). The play pool has many features that are supposed to be "fun" for kids.

But I remember the thrill of swimming to the centre of the pool and being away from everything. It felt like a real achievement and a little unsafe but in a good way.

I suppose it wasn't easy to maintain and not as "safe".


That was my first thought ok. I thought I was looking at the reflecting pool at the Washington monument or something. I’m completely in awe of the size of that pool.

It actually is closer to the reflecting pool than an Olympic pool

- Olympic pool: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympic-size_swimming_pool - Reflecting pool: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lincoln_Memorial_Reflecting_... - Fleishhacker pool: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fleishhacker_Pool




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: