Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Corporations are disbanded all the time. Wars started and ended all the time throughout history.


Sure, but there is still a risk that World War 3 will only end when all humans are dead. There is still a risk that one side will start to use nukes, and provoque a response. And that's in a human vs human war where we generally do want each other to survive.

More and more military systems have software or AI control (drones, etc). If these do get too dangerous, I doubt all current superpowers could be persuaded to stop using them.

In an AI vs humans war, the AI probably doesn't care if all humans die from nuclear winter.

(I'm not saying this is likely, I'm just saying that it's not impossible and that the fact that some corporations are disbanded doesn't really matter for AI's)


That is one of infinite hypotheticals, sure. It could also be that everyone agrees to put some failsafe in the form of EMP weapons in place to destroy a rogue AI - it's all super speculative.


You dying in a car accident is super speculative too, yet we have thousands of different actions and regulations that are put into place to reduce that from occurring.

If I had to make a bet I would say the airbag in your car is never going to go off. And yet we engineer these safety devices to ensure the most likely bad outcomes don't kill you. This is the point of studying AI safety, so we understand the actual risks of these systems simply because some low probability but existential outcomes are possible.

>It could also be that everyone agrees to put some failsafe in the form of EMP weapons in place to destroy a rogue AI

So we would commit suicide? Are we talking about EMPs in data centers that could run AI? Ooops, there goes the economy. And that doesn't address miniaturization of AI in much smaller formats in the future. Trying to build it safe in the first place is much better bet then picking what remains from ashes because we were not cautious.


A car accident isn't super speculative, nor the way these accidents happen, the injuries they can cause and so forth. There is nothing speculative or hypothetical about them.

We don't know the actual risks of something that does not exist and is vaguely characterized. Any number of hypotheticals can have existential risks with a certain probability, that is not enough to warrant study.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: