Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> One of these forces is unfettered access to social media.

I think we should reframe this to make it a bit more clear who the enemy is: We're allowing ad companies unfettered access to our kids.

It's not communicating with their friends that's a problem, it's using a medium that is incentivized to encourage poor dopamine hygiene.

These platforms are designed to harm their users because unhealthy users are more profitable than healthy users.



Too many peoples' salaries here depend on them not understanding that. The most prestigious jobs here are often considered to be FAANG, two of which are the biggest ad companies on the planet. It's just depressing really.


There are others that wouldn't take a FAANG job on principle. We may not be a majority, but there are more of us here than there are anywhere else.


Ads aren't the problem. Ad companies go out of their way to ensure their ads don't exceed the cultural average in terms of content and messaging. The problem with social media is the content kids are being fed. Communicating with their friends isn't the problem, its that they are consuming content not just from their friends, and their friends are also being influenced by content outside of their social bubble. It's the wide connectivity and the foreign ideologies that come with it.


I think it's more specific than that. You're right that the advertiser using the platform to target an ad isn't exclusively problematic. Also problematic is the person who uses the platform in a targeted way to shape the global narrative according to some agenda they have. There's something antisocial about seeking influence over people who don't know you.

In some sense perhaps the attention economy that arises from this scenario is inescapable. But we have a lot of gray area between whether we make it something to be encouraged or whether we make it something to be mitigated.

If I had kids, I'd rather they use social media that aims to connect people with their friends without giving anyone a megaphone or a lever to influence the big picture narratives in flux at any given moment. As far as I'm aware, such media are in short supply. And as software folk it is we who should be doing the supplying.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: