Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

And btw, how many features have been brought live since Musk's takeover? If I'm not wrong, at least: long tweets, paid subscriptions, community notes, native video (?), grok... Anything else? Seems quite a lot after years of stagnation.



Thanks for the reply, but you get a number of things wrong.

The 2017 "long tweets" are actually 280 characters. 4k characters tweets have been introduced in 2023.

The "subscription feature" is a content creator one, while I meant paid blue check.

"Community notes" had not been publicly launched before Musk did, renaming them from "Birdwatch".

The "native video" feature you mention is Vine, which had been discontinued.

Not saying that Musk innovated (doesn't take much to make blue checks subscription-based or to increase the length of tweets) but he did act decisively to introduce changes in the good old Twitter, something the previous CEOs had hesitated to do.


> The 2017 "long tweets" are actually 280 characters.

So, longer.

> The "subscription feature" is a content creator one, while I meant paid blue check.

I consider the paid blue checks a negative, not a positive.

> "Community notes" had not been publicly launched before Musk did

As with the long tweets, this then becomes a pretty minor tweak.

> The "native video" feature you mention is Vine, which had been discontinued.

I mentioned three iterations. The last link, in 2015, is the current native video handling.

If I, personally, went to my boss and rattled this off as a list of primary personal achievements in the past couple of years, they'd say "you're padding things"… and I'm a single developer.


> So, longer.

Yes, an order of magnitude longer.


If you were asked "what have you accomplished over the last couple of years" and your answer was "I increased the maximum character count config setting", do you expect a raise from your boss for the great work?

If you wanna make the case for "Musk accelerated innovation at Twitter", more is required than "you can make longer posts" IMO.


Chronological feed by default with a setting that actually sticks, private favorites, new media gallery, "E2E" messages.

(side note: Birdwatch was a way better name than Community Notes)


> Chronological feed by default with a setting that actually sticks…

Musk killed third-party clients, which all had that already.

> private favorites

To conceal the plunge in activity post-acquisition, and to soothe the owner. https://www.businessinsider.com/twitter-boosted-elon-musk-tw...

> new media gallery

We're not really calling a bit of a redesign "innovation", are we?

> "E2E" messages

Anything using Twitter for this in a scenario where said encryption is important is a loon, IMO. That's what Signal is for.


>Musk killed third-party clients, which all had that already.

Irrelevant for the point but yes, API changes and killing TweetDeck was a shit move.

>To conceal the plunge in activity post-acquisition, and to soothe the owner

I don't care about your opinion on that, for me it's great and made me like more posts. I don't engage in politics on Twitter.

>We're not really calling a bit of a redesign "innovation", are we?

We are listing changes. Seems like you are just biased against Musk instead of engaging in a discussion.

>Anything using Twitter for this in a scenario where said encryption is important is a loon, IMO. That's what Signal is for.

Agreed but it's a new feature.


Private likes too.


They renamed favorites to likes. It's the same thing.


Sorry, you're right of course. I was thinking of bookmarks.


Do you consider massive reduction of impression/reacheability and "shadowbans" for organically influential users features? Lots of users are seen reporting those. Tweets and replies not showing or made "unavailable", followers silently deleted or muted without user input, etc.


From your list, only grok. All the other stuff was already there.


As a medicore programmer, other than AI I would imagine the rest of the list would take 2 weeks to program and implement.


“Long tweets” could be anything from changing a config variable to rewriting massive tomes of code.

Unless you have knowledge of x’s internal code?


Keep trying, estimation is hard! You’ll improve!


Yes, you are imagining.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: