>At first your comment rubbed me the wrong way, too cynical.
It's only cynical if you think making money is bad! I think it's terrific that your average B student and up is mature enough to reliably take on tens of thousands of dollars in debt, and work hard for several years without any immediate reward, in exchange for a pretty reliable pathway towards high paying specialized labor for the rest of their lives. It spits in the face of the narrative that young people are too stupid, or too naive or whatever to have agency in their own lives.
>The only reason these courses get completed is the pace/cadence, GPA requirements to get jobs and the degree.
I cite The Case Against Education, as usual. [1]
>In the ‘real world’ you just learn enough to solve the problem in front of you and as you face more and more your knowledge tree expands. No one in their right mind would go through a syllabus-like sequence - it is just boring, dull as hell.
I cite too John D. Cook's "Just-in-case versus just-in-time" blog post. [2] I don't work through actual syllabi, but I love working through textbooks from start to finish. But you are also correct that I am emphatically not in my right mind, and my career has suffered for it. ;)
It's only cynical if you think making money is bad! I think it's terrific that your average B student and up is mature enough to reliably take on tens of thousands of dollars in debt, and work hard for several years without any immediate reward, in exchange for a pretty reliable pathway towards high paying specialized labor for the rest of their lives. It spits in the face of the narrative that young people are too stupid, or too naive or whatever to have agency in their own lives.
>The only reason these courses get completed is the pace/cadence, GPA requirements to get jobs and the degree.
I cite The Case Against Education, as usual. [1]
>In the ‘real world’ you just learn enough to solve the problem in front of you and as you face more and more your knowledge tree expands. No one in their right mind would go through a syllabus-like sequence - it is just boring, dull as hell.
I cite too John D. Cook's "Just-in-case versus just-in-time" blog post. [2] I don't work through actual syllabi, but I love working through textbooks from start to finish. But you are also correct that I am emphatically not in my right mind, and my career has suffered for it. ;)
[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_t957pTcJ0E&t=2s
[2]: https://www.johndcook.com/blog/2010/03/03/just-in-case-versu...