Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> what would you do if you're Israel?

Let in the food. Flood Gaza with food, actually, so it stops being a recruitment tool for militants.



If that solved the problem I would endorse it. I don't see how it does or how you do it.

How do you get food to all of Gaza while there is raging fighting? The biggest problem is in Gaza city where there is intense fighting. The southern areas have a lot more food. How do we flood Gaza city with food? Ceasefire? We had one. Then what?

Let's plan this in more detail. Who is going to distribute the food in Gaza? Who in Gaza has weapons and control? How is the hostage problem resolved? How do we get Hamas to not rule over Gaza any more?


> How do you get food to all of Gaza while there is raging fighting?

Berlin airdrop and pile it up at the borders from trucks for starters.

> southern areas have a lot more food

But not enough. Start there. Also, if you make food plentiful enough in the south, it will find its way north. The point, again, isn't just to starve the famine. It's also to reduce the value of food as a recruiting tool.

> How is the hostage problem resolved? How do we get Hamas to not rule over Gaza any more?

Not relevant to not starving people!


Israel has piled it up on the border many times during the conflict.

https://www.nbcnews.com/world/middle-east/gaza-food-starvati...

https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/07/24/un-refuses-to-cooper...

It's true that it's objectively hard to get the food from the border into e.g. Gaza city while a war is raging on. Israel has asked all civilians to evict Gaza city (basically for the entire duration of the war). Many people returned to Gaza city during the last ceasefire despite no green light from Israel. There is more food in the south and it's easier to get food into there.

There is an effort to get even more food into the south. For example World Central Kitchen is scaling up their operations there right now (with Israel's support). The GHF effort was also mostly focused on the south.

Air drops can't move in enough food. They're also dangerous.


> There is more food in the south and it's easier to get food into there

Yet there are still credible claims of famine in the south.

> Air drops can't move in enough food

This is nonsense. West Berlin had a civilian population of about 2.5mm [1]. Gaza is smaller. Our planes are better. We've solved this problem, but harder, before.

> They're also dangerous

What's the threat model? Initially, you'd literally air drop--no landings. Gaza isn't fielding air-defence systems.

Once you're reduced the desperation, you'd secure a couple airfields and make unsupervised drops. (This is cheaper.) You wouldn't even bother handling distribution. Again, the point is the flood the zone with so much food that it starts to become sort of worthless.

[1] https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/bomb-bl...


Feeding people is a good of its own. "We have to blockade food because distribution is logistically challenging" is ridiculous.


in this case they divert more desirable goods that they sell and make aid agencies pay protection money for "securing shipments".

as example, there was a story on Israeli news a couple of months ago, about some NGO that setup a new aid distribution network. One day they got some of their people killed in Gaza and received a phone call demanding payment "or else"


> there was a story on Israeli news

Was it credible? Who made the phone call?


story credible. channel 12 news is very solid organization and their investigations resulted in a bunch of criminal cases.

essentially ngo established this summer (july/august) new aid distribution network, I think it was at south with it's own drivers, distribution points, etc. during the time when supposedly was impossible to bring aid in gaza, but in reality it was going in.

"local interests" in gaza didn't like it, as NGO wasn't paying protection fees so they killed some of people who helped ngo in gaza and made threatening calls to person who runs NGO demanding payments or that this person will be harmed and distribution will be stopped.

not sure how it all ended. my guess it was "public" ask from military or security services to get involved in some way


If it's the events that I'm thinking of, one of the drivers killed was a Bedouin from the Tarabin family. They literally gathered hundreds of family members to record a cellphone message to the perpetrators, who were mentioned by name. In the video, dozens of illegal weapons - mostly M-16 variants - were paraded and fired in the air. Tarabin is a well-known dangerous and hostile family, the Israeli police don't interfere with them (that's why they have all the illegal weapons).

I know of other Bedouins families that have rewards for the heads of other Hamas members.


not sure. channel 12 evening news month ago or so. they talked with some women who organized ngo.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: