Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Ask HN: Why is HN so important?
4 points by keepamovin 5 days ago | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments
I recently produced a few projects that gave me an insight into the raw numbers of HN, and they're not that "impressive". We here have less MAU than your typical TikTok influencer or YouTuber. We have way loss total "subscribers" (excluding just lurkers) than your average C-tier YouTuber, or even a Rumbler.

Despite that, a crack on HN is heard around the world. A shot here can take you to the stratosphere (I know, some of my best deals and customers have come from random comments). I don't know how this can be because, the numbers dohn't lie:

each month only around 40,000 MAU contribute here. 40,000 geeks, in a "way more niche than I actually thought" orange-site internet forum, is somehow the "revolutionary salon" for where new bourgening internets are born.

How can this be? We are not special (at least, compared to the global internetizenry, I am not). And I don't think the rest of us are that special either, special in our own lives sure, but none of us have huge reach. And even if we did, I'd doubt the "handful of super influentials shaping the effects of HN globally" theory. Just seems wrong.

Despite that, somehow this little poxy orange website (sorry, mods, but you know it's true), is able to influence many things. How? God, damnit, how!?

What is the reason? I don't buy that it's the "YC" association. So what. Some hostname. Blah. That no one ever visits! Few, even fewer than here.

What is this place about, that makes it influential? I'd like to analogically understand if by comparing it with the "usenet" forums of YORE, where things like Linux and RFCs for now-standard net backbone tech were first promulgated. But that's not really the same thing.

Am I wrong? Is it uninfluential? Becuase despite the numbers (and numbers don't lie), this place seems fricking way more influential than its weight.

How can that be? It's not demographically concentrated. What is the cause of this anomaly? Ponder on that, the purpose of this question is.





EU citizen here, for several reasons:

- while HN is somewhat focussed on SV, it is coveraging a very broad global set of new & inspiring information

- HN runs flawless on nearly everyone device with superslow capacity (I have been in places where HN was the only page that was loaded because of the bad internet connection, while all other pages failed, even Google or Wikipedia). The page just loads - and this very fast

- for sure, here we do not have Ads

- from a personal perspective: So far this is the only page covering my core interests that broadly: they are arround tech, web, internet, digital, finance, economy, useful news, inspirations, psychology

- HN is that influental in my country, that local tech websites are actually copying the content from here

So let me put it that way: HN is a melting pot of a very thin group of people who are working on inspiring stuff I like.

(and I like the lurkers here: Very often there is an article about X, then someone shows up in the comments and says "Im working on X, I can explain in all details")


> We have way loss total "subscribers" (excluding just lurkers) than your average C-tier YouTuber, or even a Rumbler.

Why exclude just lurkers? HN has a lot of them: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36146958

Do you mean the average C-tier YouTuber has more than 40,000 different people commenting on their videos every month?


I think so yes. 5M lurkers

Hacker News is a friendly forum, heavily moderated, for the exchange of ideas.

It’s basically “what the internet is supposed to be like”, IMNSHO.

Ideas are influential. Everything you see started out as an idea. Don’t like what you see? Create something better, and follow through.

As for RFC’s and the like, there are github and alternatives.


> We are not special

You are special for some topic, perhaps only a niche topic. Make good comments in that topic, ask good questions in topics you are interested, upvote good comments and use the downvote button very seldom. Just use your special secret powers to make this small cornet of the internet special.


I meant it less like we have no ability and more like we’re not different to everybody else everybody has ability



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: